Choosing the right real estate broker can mean the difference between a quick sale at the desired price and months of frustration. In Quebec, there are more than 15,000 OACIQ-certified brokers. How do you find the one that suits you? Here are the 7 essential criteria.
Why choosing the right broker matters
A good broker can save you thousands of dollars and weeks of stress. Here's what an excellent broker brings to the table:
💰 Better sale price — Thanks to their market knowledge and negotiation skills
📊 What is your property worth? Get a free estimate in 2 minutes.
Estimate my property⏱️ Faster sale — Their network and marketing strategy make the difference
😌 Less stress — They handle showings, calls, paperwork and negotiations
⚖️ Legal protection — They ensure everything is compliant with the law
⚠️ Conversely, a bad broker can let your property stagnate on the market, lose you money, and turn your sale into a nightmare.
✅ Criteria #1: Experience in YOUR area
A broker who knows Outremont like the back of their hand won't be as effective in Terrebonne. Local knowledge is essential.
A local broker knows:
- Real sale prices (not just listing prices)
- Potential buyers looking in the area
- Neighborhood specifics (schools, transit, projects)
- Selling points that work locally
💡 Question to ask: "How many properties have you sold in my neighborhood in the past 12 months?"
✅ Criteria #2: Number of recent sales
Experience matters, but recent activity is even more important. A broker who sold a lot 5 years ago but little today is no longer at the top of the market.
💡 Question to ask: "How many sales have you closed this year?"
✅ Criteria #3: Marketing strategy
A good broker doesn't just list your home on Centris. They have a complete strategy to attract the right buyers.
What their strategy should include:
- 📸 Professional photos (non-negotiable!)
- 🎥 3D virtual tour or video
- 📱 Social media marketing
- 📧 Outreach to their buyer list
- 🏠 Open house events
- 🤝 Collaboration with other brokers
💡 Question to ask: "Can you show me examples of your recent listings?"
✅ Criteria #4: Communication
Nothing is more frustrating than a broker who doesn't return your calls. Communication is essential throughout the sale process.
Check:
- Response time (less than 24h = good sign)
- Communication methods (text, email, phone)
- Update frequency (weekly minimum)
- Availability for showings (evenings and weekends)
💡 Question to ask: "How and how often will you keep me informed?"
✅ Criteria #5: Commission and included services
The typical commission in Quebec is 4% to 6% (split between the seller's and buyer's broker). But beware: the cheapest is not always the best choice.
Compare what's included:
- Professional photos
- For sale sign
- Paid advertising
- Home staging or consultation
- Virtual tour
💡 Question to ask: "What exactly does your commission include? Are there any additional fees?"
✅ Criteria #6: References and reviews
Testimonials from past clients are the best indicator of what you can expect.
Where to look:
- Google Reviews
- Broker's Facebook page
- Personal website
- Ask for 2-3 references directly
💡 Question to ask: "Can you give me the contact info of 2-3 recent clients I could reach out to?"
✅ Criteria #7: Personal connection
You'll be working closely with this person for several weeks or months. Trust and rapport must be there.
Trust your instincts:
- Are they really listening to you?
- Do they answer your questions clearly?
- Do you feel comfortable?
- Are they pressuring you to sign?
✅ Good sign: A broker who asks about your needs and goals BEFORE talking about themselves.
📋 10 questions to ask during the interview
- How many properties have you sold in my neighborhood this year?
- What price do you suggest and why?
- What is your marketing strategy?
- What services are included in your commission?
- How will you communicate with me?
- What is the duration of the listing agreement?
- Can you show me examples of your listings?
- Do you have references I can contact?
- How long on average do your properties stay on the market?
- What happens if I'm not satisfied with your services?
🚫 5 pitfalls to avoid
❌ Pitfall #1: Choosing the broker who promises the highest price
Some inflate the price to get the contract, then ask you to lower it after a few weeks.
❌ Pitfall #2: Choosing solely based on commission
A cheaper broker who sells for less costs you more in the end.
❌ Pitfall #3: Hiring a friend or family member
Personal relationships can complicate business. Keep it professional.
❌ Pitfall #4: Not reading the listing agreement
Check the duration, cancellation conditions, and fees.
❌ Pitfall #5: Rushing
Meet at least 2-3 brokers before deciding. Take the time to compare.
✅ Checklist: The 7 essential criteria
☑️ Experience in your specific area
☑️ Number of recent sales (15+ per year = good)
☑️ Complete marketing strategy
☑️ Clear and responsive communication
☑️ Commission justified by services
☑️ Good references and reviews
☑️ Positive personal connection
Find the ideal broker for your sale
CourtiConnect connects you for free with OACIQ-certified brokers who know your area.
🏠 Find my broker for free100% free • No commitment • Response within 24h
Stay informed on the real estate market
Get our weekly insights and tips delivered straight to your inbox.
📚 Related articles
📊 What is your property worth? Get a free estimate in 2 minutes.
Estimate my property